Why temperature loggers, alarms, and VVM
labels are not enough
It is well known that
vaccines are temperature sensitive. They are easily inactivated by exposure to temperatures outside of the standard 2 oC
to 8 oC refrigerated storage range (1,
2). Both high and low
(freezing) temperatures cause inactivation, and recent reports show that
inadvertent freezing in the cold chain is a larger problem than heat
inactivation.
Temperature loggers, temperature alarms, and
VVM (vaccine vial monitors) have historically been used to monitor the
vaccine cold chain, and indeed this technology has greatly improved vaccine
safety and efficacy worldwide. Although highly useful, however, this
earlier technology has certain drawbacks. These drawbacks are:
Temperature
loggers must be downloaded and interpreted. This usually occurs
weeks or months after the cold chain break has occurred, and analysis
usually takes place far away from the problem area. Due to distance
and time, it is often difficult or impossible to locate the personnel
involved in the actual cold-chain break. As a result, corrective
action is slow and difficult, and much vaccine may be lost.
Temperature alarms that warn on preset values (e.g. freezing or high
temperature) are almost impossible to correctly set. They either warn
prematurely or too late, and give information of limited value. Thus
they tend to be disregarded.
VVM (vaccine vial monitors) do not
warn about freezing damage (the most common cause of cold chain failure).
VVM are only available for a few limited vaccine types. Because VVM
rely upon chemical indicators, it is often difficult to precisely tune a
VVM to match the stability characteristics of a particular vaccine.
Thus development of a new VVM typically takes several years, and requires
the active participation of the vaccine manufacturer. Since
the vaccine label is changed, use of a VVM may require additional
regulatory review. Many manufacturers have been slow or reluctant to
implement VVMs.
The ideal vaccine monitor?
The ideal vaccine monitor might have the
following characteristics:
Instantly warn when the cold chain breaks
(relative to a particular vaccine's stability)
Detect all cold chain problems, not just
elevated temperature
Accurately report vaccine stability -
report real problems, not just false alarms
Log (record) temperatures before and after
the cold chain break (for later analysis)
Be instantly customized to a particular
vaccine's time-temperature stability curve
Not require large amounts of
manufacturer's time and expense
Be capable of being implemented without
additional manufacturer effort
Not require large amounts of regulatory
review
Be easy to validate
Be simple, quick, and easy to implement
Consider the LifeTrack
The LifeTrack has all the features of the
"ideal" vaccine monitor listed above. Essentially the device combines
the best features of a temperature logger, temperature alarm, and VVM into a
new type of device that brings vaccine cold chain monitoring to a higher
level of flexibility, precision, and control. See our publication in
Vaccine.
Packaging the LifeTrack
Ideally one LifeTrack unit is packaged per
carton of vaccine vials. The unit should be attached to the carton by
a moderately strong adhesive, or as a subsection of the carton, so that the
linkage between the LifeTrack unit and the vaccine vials is maintained
throughout the cold chain. The LifeTrack unit should be added to the
vaccine carton as soon as possible after manufacturing, and should be left with the carton until
all the vaccine vials have been used.